Returns and RMAs
Switching returns on, what the customer sees, approving and declining, and what happens to the stock when the goods come back.
A return is a record, not an email thread. The customer asks through a form on your shop, you approve or decline it, and the goods, the money and the stock all move against the same request so nothing is settled twice.
Returns are on the Pro and Enterprise plans.
Switching It On
Settings, Returns, then tick Accept return requests.
Nothing appears on your storefront until you do, and nothing is lost if you switch it off again: existing requests stay where they are and simply stop being added to.
Set the Return Window (Days) before you announce it anywhere. It counts from the day an order was delivered, falling back to the day it shipped, falling back to the day it was placed, so a shop that never marks anything delivered still gets a sensible window rather than none at all.
What the Customer Does
They start at /returns on your shop. Somebody signed in picks the order from their order history. A guest gives the order number and the email on the order, which is what proves the order is theirs.
Then they choose which lines to send back and how many of each, say why, and submit. They get an RMA number straight away and a link to a page that follows the request.
Part of an order, not all of it
Half an order comes back far more often than all of it, so a return is per line with quantities. Somebody returning one of three copies says so, and the other two stay sold.
Letting Them Say What They Want
Under How a Return Is Settled, What the Customer May Ask For sets which settlements the form offers: a refund, store credit, an exchange or a replacement.
The form asks which they would prefer and tells them the choice is subject to your approval. Somebody returning a shirt in the wrong size usually wants the right size rather than their money back, and a shop that refunds them has lost the sale for nothing.
Their answer is a preference, never a decision. It appears on the review screen as They asked for, and the Approve form offers it first. You can still choose differently.
Tick nothing there and the question is left off the form.
Reviewing a Request
Sales, Returns. The tabs are Awaiting Review, Approved and Pending Return, Settled and All, each with a count, so you can see at a glance whether there is anything to do.
Open one and you get the request, who sent it, the order behind it, the lines and the figures.
Approving
Approve records what you have agreed to, which may be less than was asked for. Somebody who asks for three back and is allowed two is told two rather than being refused outright and invited to ask again.
You set the agreed total, any restocking fee, and how it will be settled. The customer is emailed the instructions, the RMA number to write on the package, and the date the approval runs out.
Declining
Decline needs a reason, because the reason is the whole email. Somebody who has been refused is holding goods they expected to send back, and "no" without a because is the start of a chargeback. What you type is sent to them in your own words.
When the Goods Arrive
Mark Received when the package turns up. Nothing goes back on the shelf yet.
Check and Restock is where you say what condition each line is in:
- Resellable puts it back into stock at the location you choose.
- Damaged records it as returned without adding to sellable stock.
- Write off records it as gone.
Only resellable lines touch your stock, which is the whole reason the step exists. A damaged item that quietly went back on the shelf gets sold again and comes straight back.
Settling It
Settle carries out the resolution and tells the customer it is done.
- A refund goes back to the processor that took the payment, the same as refunding from the order.
- Store credit is added to the customer's balance and offered at their next checkout. A guest has no account to hold a balance, so their credit arrives as a gift certificate code instead.
- Exchange, replacement and repair are recorded so the request can be closed, and you arrange them yourself.
The restocking fee, if you set one, is taken off here and shown to the customer as its own line rather than as a smaller number with no explanation.
Settle here, not on the order
Refunding straight from the order leaves the return open and the two records disagreeing about what was paid back. Settle the return and let it issue the refund.
Deciding Automatically
Two settings under Deciding Automatically:
Approve every request on arrival is for a no questions asked policy. The instructions go out immediately and nothing waits for you.
Or Approve Automatically Below approves anything worth less than the amount you set. Reading a request often costs more than the goods are worth.
Leave both off to review everything by hand.
What the Customer Sees Afterwards
Each return has its own page showing the items with the reason on each line, the arithmetic including any restocking fee, and where the request has got to with dates.
Somebody signed in also gets My Returns in their account, listing every request against their account. A return raised while signed out is linked to the account automatically the next time that person signs in, so it stops showing as a guest request to both of you.
The Emails
Five to the customer and one to you, all editable under Settings, Email Templates:
| When | |
|---|---|
| Return Requested | They submit the form |
| Return Approved | You approve, carrying the instructions and the deadline |
| Return Declined | You decline, carrying your reason |
| Return Received | The package reaches you |
| Return Resolved | You settle it |
| Return Request (To You) | A request arrives, to the addresses under Telling You |
The approval email carries whatever you write in Return Instructions. Leave that empty and it falls back to your store address; leave both empty and the email simply has no instructions in it, which is rarely what you want.
Settings in Full
| Setting | What it does |
|---|---|
| Accept return requests | The switch. Nothing is on your storefront without it |
| Return Window (Days) | How long after delivery a return may be asked for |
| Only signed in customers may request a return | Turns off the guest lookup |
| Days to Ship an Approved Return | How long an approval lasts before it expires |
| Open Requests Allowed per Customer | Stops one person opening twenty at once |
| Above the Form, After Submitting | Your own wording on the storefront pages |
| Return Instructions | Sent with every approval |
| Reasons | The list the customer picks from, each able to require a photograph or an explanation |
| Questions | Extra fields of your own on the form |
| Usually Settled With | What the review screen offers first |
| What the Customer May Ask For | What the form offers them |
| Return Shipping Paid By | Recorded for reporting and for who pays |
| Restocking Fee (%) | Shown to the customer before they confirm |
| Give back the original shipping on a full return | Usually off for a change of mind, on when the fault was yours |
A Workable Rule
Set the window and the instructions before you switch it on. Approve or decline the same day, because the clock the customer is watching starts when they ask, not when you read it. Check the goods before you settle, so the money follows the goods rather than the promise.
